High Anxiety
The days of wine and IPOs of six months ago a
fading memory, L.A.'s dot-coms are suddenly fighting for
their livelihoods.
September, 2000
John Collier should be basking in this moment.
Standing on a red carpet, his face lit by banks of
swiveling klieg lights, Collier watches as a pair of
sweet young things in snakeskin pants glide through the
front door of the West Hollywood nightclub rented out
tonight for the launch of Icebox, an animation Web site
he dreamed up a year ago while sitting at a kitchen
table with an old Harvard writing buddy. "Everything
about this is bigger than we ever planned," says
Collier, one of Icebox's four cofounders and a
television writer whose credits include The
Simpsons. "We planned on getting 8 writers to
contribute -- we ended up getting 60. We planned on
raising a million. We got $17 million."
Inside, a whirlpool of Web-shop workers, development
execs and animators swirls around a 10-foot-long ice
statue molded into the company's logo. Run-D.M.C., hired
as the evening's entertainment, plays for a packed house
of 1,300 from the entertainment and Internet arenas --
EarthLink founder Sky Dayton is nibbling a stick of
satay across the room from Rod Stewart; Tori Spelling is
lounging in the back near Mike Judge. The bar is open,
the hors d'oeuvres are plentiful, and the guests are
madly cross-pollinating.
Collier is showing few signs of satisfaction. In
fact, he's looking downright depressed. "I would have
preferred to charge admission for this," he says. "I see
an open bar and my heart just stops."
Call it a symptom of the new Internet anxiety. All
across L.A., Internet execs who just months ago were
posing for Helmut Newton portraits and pontificating on
their part in the information revolution are suddenly
scrutinizing bar tabs and retooling business models.
Meanwhile, capital is fast drying up on a whole category
of locally produced Web attractions that were billed as
the beginning of a new era of interactive entertainment.
"We knew the bubble was going to burst sometime,"
says Web consultant Liz Heller, doyenne of L.A.'s
digital set and former vice president of new media at
Capitol Records. "All we talked about before April was
`When's it going to happen?' Then it happened, and we
were all, like, `waaaaaah!'"
The meltdown of the Nasdaq in April marked a turning
point for the whole wired economy, but nowhere has the
depression been felt more keenly than in the region
boosters call "the digital coast." That's because the
very things that Hollywood is so good at -- spending
money! looking fabulous! making mediocre television! --
have suddenly become big no-no's in the world of new
media.
Frugality is in, along with a concept altogether
absent from most Web sites spawned in the image of
Hollywood: profitability. And just as fast as they have
popped up, L.A.'s dot-com enterprises have been scaling
back or biting the dust. The Web broadcaster Digital
Entertainment Network was first to go, flaming out in
March amid lurid tales of mismanagement, profligate
spending and a lawsuit alleging that the founder
molested a teenage boy. Farther down the coast, the
founder of the San Juan Capistrano start-up Pixelon was
ousted after hosting a fall-of-Rome launch party that
cost upwards of $15 million (it didn't help that he was
later exposed as a convicted con artist and fugitive
wanted by authorities in Virginia and Tennessee).
Then there are the more mundane cutbacks and
consolidations, claiming such previously red-hot L.A.
start-ups as eToys (which saw its stock plummet from a
high of $84 per share to a lowly $6), FasTV (which
closed suddenly in July and laid off its entire staff),
Sony's on-line game division (which laid off 60 Los
Angeles workers), eParties (which closed its Santa
Monica office) and LOADtv (which laid off 42 people).
Amid the open-plan workspaces of L.A. Web shops -- which
have lately gone from funky and cheerful to creepy and
oppressive -- watercooler chatter has turned from stock
options to severance packages.
"The Web is turning out to be Hollywood's Vietnam,"
says David Wertheimer, a former executive at Paramount
who heads the entertainment site WireBreak.com. "You've
got a lot of people who came in with no idea what they
were doing and got beaten up badly. Now they're
retreating and claiming victory."
So now that prickly skepticism has set in, what's a
pumped-up Hollywood dot-commer to do? Some industry
refugees have cut their losses and fled back to jobs
they ditched to join the gold rush, or headed north to
more stable and less sexy outfits in Silicon Valley.
Those staying the course are eliminating perks, shelving
plans for mind-boggling IPOs and reinventing themselves
as skinflint technologists while boldly crowing about
the removal of fringe competitors. In private, nearly
everyone admits to a wistful nostalgia for the
easy-money glory days of ... six months ago. "People in
this space built fast, hired fast and spent fast," says
Heller. "Now, all of a sudden, it's all very scary and
very competitive."
•••
FOR MANY WORKING IN THE L.A. INTERNET industry, the
recent mood swing feels like deja vu all over again. A
similar outburst of anxiety swept across the basin in
1998, when the first crop of Hollywood's on-line
experiments withered and died. The Internet industry in
Los Angeles actually dates to October 29, 1969, when a
Bronx-born computer scientist at UCLA named Leonard
Kleinrock flipped a switch on a refrigerator-size
processor that sent information spewing through a phone
line to a campus computer. He called it "packet
switching." The idea was picked up by computer
scientists at MIT and Stanford, who further developed
the vast shared network that became the Internet. And
while fortunes were eventually made on the new
technology in Silicon Valley and Seattle, entrepreneurs
in Los Angeles were late to the game. It took the
arrival of out-of-town emissaries from Microsoft,
America Online and Intel to get the L.A. Internet
industry off the ground.
Big tech companies hit Hollywood in the mid-'90s with
a mission: Add pizzazz and production values to a
network originally used to transmit academic and
military data. Microsoft enlisted a staff of fringe
Hollywood players to build the Microsoft Network (MSN),
an on-line broadcaster featuring "channels" and "shows."
America Online wooed television legend Brandon Tartikoff
to develop a slate of Web attractions. Intel invested
heavily in a Marina del Rey start-up called American
Cybercast that produced an on-line Melrose Place
knockoff called The Spot.
While buzz began to build about this new genre of
entertainment, the people doing the work -- mostly
techies who had previously worked in CD-ROMs and video
games -- were still very much outsiders in Hollywood. "I
remember when I first moved here and told people I made
Web pages. I might as well have told them I made shoes,"
says Peter Luttrell, a software engineer who got his
start in the digital stone age of 1994. "They couldn't
have cared less." Web producers like The Spot's
Scott Zakarin fought hard against the geek rep, casting
themselves as rogue pioneers leading the way toward the
ballyhooed "convergence" of the Internet and
broadcasting. But a funny thing happened on the way to
the promised land: Everyone went bust.
Facing fierce competition from AOL, MSN scrapped its
original programming in 1996. The death of Tartikoff
came two months before the launch of America Online's
doomed Entertainment Asylum. And after burning through
$6 million in one year, American Cybercast declared
bankruptcy in 1997. The problem for these
entertainment-oriented sites remains the problem today:
The vast majority of people who spend time on the
Internet chug along on dial-up modems, and for them,
video and other so-called broadband content are pretty
much unwatchable. Besides the technical difficulties,
the economics are messy (as would-be Web programmers
discovered, content is appallingly costly--even the
subcable drivel that appeared on most Web sites), and
on-line ads generated more irritation than revenue.
The first wave of entertainment-based sites had
scarcely vanished into the ether when a second, more
moneyed Hollywood player began poking around for a piece
of the action, and on-line entertainment once again got
hot. Among the dealmakers who launched Internet
initiatives in 1999 were DreamWorks chiefs Steven
Spielberg, David Geffen and Jeffrey Katzenberg, Imagine
Entertainment heads Ron Howard and Brian Grazer (who
teamed up on the short-film Web site Pop.com), former
Nickelodeon president Geraldine Laybourne (whose Oxygen
Media is built around a Web site), superstar manager
Brad Grey (a backer of the entertainment site Z.com) and
former Universal CEO Frank Biondi (who formed a venture
capital fund). In less than a year, Disney lost the
heads of its movie studio and cable operations as well
as two top theme-park designers to dot-com start-ups.
What lured Hollywood to the Net a second time was
simple envy. The huge run-ups in Web stock prices
created enough millionaires that Industry execs
accustomed customed to making obscene amounts of money
looked on longingly as Internet entrepreneurs set new
standards for obscenity. One January morning in 1999, a
collective gasp went up in Tinseltown when news that a
scrappy little Marina del Rey Web start-up called
GeoCities had just sold out to Yahoo! for a reported
$3.56 billion (mostly stock, but still ...). "What the
Web did in Los Angeles is something no industry has ever
managed to do in this town: It made entertainment
executives feel out of touch and uncool," says Sean
Suhl, a 25-year-old Web whiz kid who began his career
designing sites for studios and TV shows. "They all
wanted in."
Meanwhile, another wave of marketing and corporate
players began rushing in from the rapidly consolidating
music industry. "We all looked around for something with
the same sense of excitement as the music business in
its nascent period," says producer Bob Ezrin, who quit
the recording industry after producing such acts as Pink
Floyd and KISS to launch a site called Enigma Digital.
"We were drawn in by the allure of the pioneering
spirit, the informality, the constant drip of
adrenaline," Ezrin adds. "And, of course, the
possibility of getting very rich very quick."
Mostly, these entertainment-industry refugees were
not disappointed. Jeff Pollack and Benny Medina,
creators of the sitcom Fresh Prince of Bel-Air,
are still awed by their experience shopping around the
idea for Thirsty.com, a Web site that delivers
youth-oriented news on fashion, music and celebrities
with the speed and seriousness of a Wall Street stock
report. "Everywhere we went, we had unbridled enthusiasm
across the board," says Pollack. "We would walk into a
room, and the desire to say yes was palpable." He
remembers one meeting with a Web company called Boundary
that had previously expressed guarded interest in
investing: "We walked into this meeting with a bunch of
guys just grinning from ear to ear. They were
particularly happy because Boundary had made $800
million that day."
Along with the fatter paychecks came oversize
attitudes. Hollywood's high-tech insta-moguls emerged as
altogether different creatures from the socially stunted
brainiacs who rule Silicon Valley. "A lot of the
new-media guys are basically geeks who couldn't get
dates in high school--and they get a tremendous thrill
from being courted by these entertainment guys," says
Jeff Haber, an actor and screenwriter who launched the
Web start-up Point-Click-Purchase. "And then you've got
the entertainment guys who just want the money that the
geek guys have. So everyone's one's wearing black, and
everyone desperately wants to be a star."
This high-school-with-money model became the norm at
Web shops like LOADtv, cofounded by a 29-year-old
junk-mail mogul named Morgan Warstler. Flush with
venture capital, Warstler rented an old bank building on
the Sunset Strip and filled it with staff from his
native Canton, Ohio. Former and current employees say
they logged 75-hour workweeks producing Web programming
targeted at what current CEO Jack Kennedy calls
"low-hanging fruit" -- Gen Y computer nerds and skate
punks. Employees, say sources at the company, were
regaled with plans to topple the Hollywood studio
system; one former staffer and a job applicant were told
the black and white tiles in front of the building had
been arranged in a pattern that resembled digital code.
The secret message: FUCK YOU. (LOADtv cofounder Matt
McFee says he's "never heard that one" and that
employees were under no obligation to work such long
hours. Warstler did not return calls for comment.)
Such hubris was not only tolerated but practically
celebrated in a marketplace suddenly awash in venture
capital. In 1999, $2.5 billion was funneled into
Internet ventures in L.A. and Orange Counties, 200
percent more than in 1998, according to the
PriceWaterhouseCoopers Money Tree Survey. One start-up
that embraced the windfall was StreamSearch.com, a St.
Louis-based search engine for broadband content that
hosted a party at the Playboy Mansion in April featuring
dinner for 500, tours of the grounds led by Playboy
Bunnies and a concert by the Brian Setzer Orchestra.
StreamSearch CEO Robert Shambro says he took some heat
for the event, especially coming the week of the first
trembles of the Nasdaq. "It wasn't like we just went and
burned a million bucks," Shambro says. "It was a chance
to bring together major investors and major talent. I
would do it again in a second."
At the height of the boom, even the lowliest worker
bees developed a hearty sense of entitlement. Luttrell,
one of the first employees of the Digital Entertainment
Network, remembers the stone-faced salary demands of
staffers hired to proofread text: "I kept telling them,
`Dude, you're copy editors--copy editors don't make
$78,000 a year.'"
An executive at an L.A.-based Web start-up recalls
interviewing freelance programmers. "They wanted catered
lunches, stock options, overtime pay after six
o'clock--or else they'd walk," she says. "I'd look at
these guys right out of college and want to tell them,
`Look, that's just not how business works.' But what
could I say? That's the way it did work."
•••
MOST OF WHAT Hollywood has done wrong in its rush to
go digital is summed up in the story of the Digital
Entertainment Network. The smoking crater of this once
white-hot Santa Monica start-up has become an instant
object lesson in the L.A. dot-com community.
DEN was established in late 1998 by a 40-year-old
technologist named Marc Collins-Rector, who convinced
investors, including onetime senatorial candidate
Michael Huffington, that DEN would rival network
television in programming for the Gen Y set.
Collins-Rector's cofounders were a 24-year-old computer
enthusiast from Michigan named Chad Shackley and a
17-year-old child actor named Brock Pierce. The three
lived together in a hilltop estate in Encino rumored to
have been owned by hip-hop kingpin Suge Knight. Within a
year, the company had raised more than $33 million and
amassed a staff that would number more than 250. The
founders threw lavish parties and lured top executives
from Disney and Capitol Records with salaries topping $1
million.
Luttrell says DEN management wanted nothing less than
to reinvent the Web. "They came into this like, `We've
arrived -- the Web can start now,'" he says. "The thing
was that they hired these people who knew a great deal
about the Internet, and then never listened to any of
them."
Programming kicked off with an amateurish serial
called Chad's World, which revolved around a teen
runaway from Michigan who shacks up with a gay couple in
a California estate. The show failed to gain a
following, setting an example for such programs as the
T&A bonanza Frat Ratz and the pandering
Latino drama Tales from the Eastside. None of
these omens stopped DEN's founders from filing a $75
million IPO and chartering a 747 to New York to
celebrate the occasion. Afshin David Youssefyeh, who
worked as DEN's director of on-line marketing, remembers
the IPO party as a tony affair at the SoHo Grand Hotel,
where employees shared an open bar with the likes of
Michael Stipe and Leonardo DiCaprio.
As it turned out, DEN's founders never got their
stock windfall. Two days before the IPO party in New
York, a lawsuit was filed in New Jersey accusing
Collins-Rector of sexual misconduct with a 13-year-old
former employee. Collins-Rector denied the charges but
settled the suit a month later. The lawsuit was a public
embarrassment, dashing the company's hopes of a public
offering and forcing all three of a DEN's founders to
resign. New management headed by former Disney executive
David Neuman tried to salvage the company, to no avail.
The end finally came in May as the remaining 200
employees were issued curt apologies and pink slips.
To those who worked there, the failure of DEN had
less to do with the legal troubles of the founder than
with the mind-set of Hollywood newcomers. "For a
start-up to succeed, you need to work your ass off,"
says Youssefyeh, who fled Hollywood for a job in Silicon
Valley after DEN's demise. "These Hollywood guys just
don't want to get their hands dirty. It's against
everything they're about."
Journalist Matt Welch, who was hired to develop a
news division for the network, says the collapse will go
down as a monument to mammoth egos. "DEN was the poster
child of Internet excess," he says. "In terms of grossly
overpaying executives who don't know anything about the
Internet, this was the ultimate."
•••
DEN DID NOT GO DOWN ALONE. Its collapse came on the
heels of a widespread retreat from the local Internet
arena. Investment in Los Angeles- and Orange
County-based Web businesses plummeted from $850 million
in the last three months of 1999 to $421 million between
January and April 2000. Hardest hit were e-tailers, but
the tide had also turned against those sites that focus
on creating content. In the heyday of DEN, the
catchphrase was "Content is king." Post-DEN, content is
barely royalty.
The tune has definitely changed at LOADtv, the
would-be digital update of an old Hollywood studio,
producing and delivering programs on the Internet via
its own branded video player. Initial programming
included cooking shows, movie-clip packages and a comedy
starring NewsRadio ham Andy Dick. But when capital ran
low in April, cofounder Warstler stepped aside, and
Kennedy, the new CEO, promptly laid off nearly half of
the 97 employees and scrapped all original programming.
"Big changes had to be made," says Kennedy. "We had to
concentrate on delivery, not the programming itself --
these are two entirely different animals."
In appeals to investors, Kennedy has done everything
possible to shake the glitzy rep that had become the
hallmark of DEN. "We're no sexier than FedEx," he says
proudly. "Our goal is to be as invisible as possible.
That runs counter to the culture of this industry, but
if we're going to make it, we've got to stay focused on
our core business."
Other wanna-be Web programmers have become champions
of even more humdrum "revenue streams." Webstation.com
was founded by a pair of entrepreneurs with no previous
Web experience: actress Soleil Moon Frye, who starred in
the '80s sitcom Punky Brewster, and securities trader
Steve Fischer. When DEN was at its peak, the pair filed
for an IPO totaling $36 million, planning a Web network
that would broadcast concerts, fashion shows and extreme
sporting events. But with DEN in ashes, Webstation was
drastically restructured. "Once that deal was killed, so
was ours," says Fischer. "We saw the writing on the
wall." Today, Fischer and Frye run an on-line
marketplace for discount DVDs. "I guess it's about
crawling before you walk," says a humbled Frye.
•••
THE CHEST-THUMPING ARROGANCE common among Internet
execs six months ago has been replaced with a
levelheadedness that borders on gloom. When cash was
flowing, Webheads talked about the Internet as an
uncharted world of vast possibilities. Now it's all
about "multitiered revenue models" and "traditional
valuation metrics."
The new mantra is "Monetize it!" -- a bottom-line
call to arms that's Greek to most Industry dealmakers,
says Jose Royo, a former instructor at Harvard who is
now chief technical officer of the Santa Monica Web site
Broadband Sports. "You just can't run an Internet
company the same way you run a Hollywood studio," Royo
says. "The more extravagant Hollywood attitudes, all the
chauffeurs and parties--that really doesn't work in this
space."
Many Internet executives claim to revel in the new
thriftiness. Wertheimer, a former executive at Oracle
and NeXT, says he never gave in to the indulgences that
sank other Hollywood start-ups. His entertainment site
WireBreak.com operates with a small staff and few
frills; visitors to his Venice studio, seated in the
lobby on a bench ripped out of the back of a company
van, got the message immediately. "That's what our
company is all about," Wertheimer says. "It's about how
to do more with less."
According to Wertheimer, all the recent shakeout did
was cull the weak and deluded, who were in the game for
the wrong reasons. "It weeded out the people who thought
they could add a dot-com to the name of their production
company and start printing money," he says. "The
shakeout pressed the RESET button. People have to start
working for a living again, which is a good thing."
The work ethic has been taken up most ardently by the
suits financing the industry who until recently seemed
to base decisions more on hunches than on due diligence.
Randall Kaplan formed the Brentwood-based JUMP Investors
after ditching a career as a corporate lawyer. Kaplan
says high-tech venture capitalists have become obsessed
with the fine print. "I know investors who saw their
portfolio values fall as much as 80 percent this year,"
he notes. "That's a big hit. Now they're carefully going
through the methodology to determine if these start-ups
are ever going to turn a profit."
In this new climate, the kinds of on-line start-ups
hatched in Hollywood are having a tough time justifying
their existence. "You can't name any successful
entertainment Internet companies, because they don't
exist," says Kaplan.
Others maintain that the conventional wisdom will
soon swing back in favor of on-line entertainment. Steve
Stanford, a former ICM agent and now CEO of Icebox, says
the name of the game is longevity. Start-ups that hang
on to see capital swarm back toward content -- which
Stanford says is inevitable once DSL and other broadband
connections become common -- will be richly rewarded.
"The Internet today is radically different from what it
will be in three years," he says. "Anybody who takes a
too narrow view will miss the boat."
And as long as Web sites are hosted in Hollywood, the
local Internet industry will never be completely overrun
by pennypinchers or techies. Kevin Wendle, a former Fox
vice president who runs the site iFilm, says that
Internet execs who reject Hollywood turn their backs on
tremendous talent -- and potential financiers. "Right
now a lot of Internet companies are trying to take a
wrecking ball to Hollywood," he says. "That's a mistake
-- you've got some of the smartest and most creative
people in the world here. We should embrace this town."
Still, no self-respecting Hollywood dealmaker would
miss the chance to become the Louis B. Mayer of a whole
new medium. And if Hollywood is good at anything, it's
forgetting the past. So expect another round of wretched
excess as the Industry and the Internet -- seemingly the
most inevitable yet diffident of bedfellows -- pursue
their balky pas de deux.
"Hollywood is always going to produce elements of
Babylon," says DEN's Welch. "There're always going to be
great parties in mansions with prostitutes and tons of
cocaine--and thank God for that."